C. DISAGREEMENT RATES

C. DISAGREEMENT RATES

The Disagreement Rates measure the percentage of published opinions in which two justices cast opposing votes, one voting with the majority, the other voting with the dissent. The rate for each year covers the period of April 1 of the previous year through March 31 of the year indicated. A separate table is presented for each justice, indicating his or her disagreement rates with each of the other justices.

1. CHIEF JUSTICE RON GEORGE

JUSTICE	1997	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004	2005
BAXTER	17	12	16	7	13	10	12	11	9
BROWN	13	16	22	17	18	12	20	18	11
CHIN	6	7	13	7	10	7	11	8	4
KENNARD	27	22	22	25	19	17	13	15	14
MOSK	24	22	25	26	14	22
MORENO						7	15	5	3
WERDEGAR	12	9	13	14	14	13	5	11	8

2. JUSTICE MARVIN BAXTER

JUSTICE	1997	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004	2005
GEORGE	17	12	16	7	13	10	12	11	9
BROWN	18	12	17	15	10	3	8	10	7
CHIN	10	7	12	10	9	4	5	8	4
KENNARD	24	30	32	24	22	18	24	23	18
MOSK	35	30	42	29	22	26
MORENO						15	18	15	10
WERDEGAR	20	18	27	17	19	20	12	15	12

3. JUSTICE JANICE ROGERS BROWN

JUSTICE	1997	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004	2005
GEORGE	13	16	22	17	18	12	20	18	11
BAXTER	18	12	17	15	10	3	8	10	7
CHIN	15	16	21	14	14	7	12	10	7
KENNARD	27	37	32	23	22	18	30	24	19
MOSK	27	33	42	34	19	26
MORENO						22	24	22	13
WERDEGAR	24	19	30	28	15	21	19	22	14

4. JUSTICE MING CHIN

JUSTICE	1997	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004	2005
GEORGE	6	7	13	7	10	7	11	8	4
BAXTER	10	7	12	10	9	4	5	8	4
BROWN	15	16	21	14	14	7	12	10	7
KENNARD	26	28	33	25	21	14	30	16	17
MOSK	21	27	31	30	18	22
MORENO						15	24	13	6
WERDEGAR	16	17	23	14	14	18	19	15	9

5. JUSTICE JOYCE KENNARD

JUSTICE	1997	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004	2005
GEORGE	27	22	22	25	19	17	13	15	14
BAXTER	24	30	32	24	22	18	24	23	18
BROWN	27	37	32	23	22	18	30	24	19
CHIN	26	28	33	25	21	14	22	16	17
MOSK	28	22	24	25	20	11
MORENO						22	19	12	12
WERDEGAR	16	17	21	20	15	13	14	9	9

6. JUSTICE STANLEY MOSK

JUSTICE	1997	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002
GEORGE	24	22	25	26	14	22
BAXTER	35	30	42	29	22	26
BROWN	27	33	42	34	19	26
CHIN	21	27	31	30	18	22
KENNARD	28	22	24	25	20	11
WERDEGAR	18	17	20	20	17	19

7. JUSTICE CARLOS MORENO

JUSTICE	2002	2003	2004	2005
GEORGE	7	15	5	3
BAXTER	15	18	15	11
BROWN	22	24	22	13
CHIN	15	19	13	6
KENNARD	22	20	12	12
WERDEGAR	22	14	8	6

8. JUSTICE KATHRYN WERDEGAR

JUSTICE	1997	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004	2005
GEORGE	12	9	13	14	14	13	5	11	8
BAXTER	20	18	27	17	19	20	12	15	12
BROWN	24	19	30	28	15	21	19	22	14
CHIN	16	17	23	14	14	18	14	15	9
KENNARD	16	17	21	20	15	13	14	9	9
MOSK	18	17	20	20	17	19
MORENO						22	14	8	6